Monday, May 4, 2020

Here is a great example of horrible journalism

Death toll rises in Georgia as Governor Kemp reopens state

So let's start with the opening paragraph:

Some states, including Texas and Tennessee, have seen spikes in new coronavirus cases and deaths following the relaxation of social distancing measures. A model from researchers previously based at MIT previously projected that the death rate could double after lifting social distancing measures in Georgia.

First of all Texas has not seen a "spike" in new cases. They had peaked at around 1441 back in mid April and have not reached that plateau again. Yesterday they reported approximately 850 cases. Today they have reported less than 400. Tennessee saw a two day increase (which would not have had anything do with reopening) and since then, the numbers have been normal, if not falling. Secondly, an MIT model is not a fact. It's a guess.

Moving on to what is actually happening:

Still, Gov. Brian Kemp lifted the statewide shelter-in-place order for most residents on May 1, with the exception of the elderly and “medically fragile.” Since then, there have been 155 newly confirmed cases of COVID-19, according to state data, and six deaths.
At the same time, the number of new cases has been declining over time. After reaching a peak of 898 new cases on April 20, the next highest was 788 on April 27 and has dropped off significantly since then. However, the state tracker says that some confirmed cases over the last 14 days may not yet be accounted for due to pending test results or unreported illnesses.

So there really isn't any indication that there actually has been a rise in cases or deaths, although they suggest that the data is incomplete. For reference, New York (which is still shut down) reported over a 1000 deaths since May 1st vs the single digit daily reported by Georgia.

But wait... there is more to the story. Perhaps the ending will provide some cover for a giant headline that doesn't appear to be justified by the story itself.

The pandemic has disproportionately affected the black population in Georgia, which makes up about 32 percent of the total population. More than 10,000 COVID-19 patients are black, out of 29,011 cases in the state as of May 4, which is greater than any other racial group.

Well there you have it. The headline might be bogus, but we now know that the Covid-19 virus is racist.

40 comments:

Anonymous said...


Well there you have it. The headline might be bogus, but we now know that the Covid-19 virus is racist.

lead story in my local liberal rag:

Albany County's black residents hospitalized at disproportionate rate from coronavirus

New data compare black, white hospitalization, ICU and fatality rates


https://www.timesunion.com/news/article/Albany-County-s-black-residents-hospitalized-at-15244758.php

Commonsense said...

So hospitals caring for black people is now racist?

I don't understand the headline.

Anonymous said...

Oh Look, Slow Joe.
"Joe Biden: Coronavirus an ‘Incredible Opportunity’ to ‘Fundamentally Transform’ AmericaTwitter/@SteveGuest"

Anonymous said...

How clueless is Creepy

Anonymous said...

So hospitals caring for black people is now racist?

I don't understand the headline.


liberals just can't help themselves. everything must be made about racism, victimhood, inequality, etc. lather, rinse repeat. all it has ever really been is a cynical attempt to keep blacks ON the liberal plantation so they can "keep votin' democrat for the next 200 years."

Anonymous said...

President Trump just killed the vote from home concept.
The US House wants it. The US Senate Doesn't. It will never get to his desk.
Remember Federal Voting Laws apply to Federal Offices.

anonymous said...

What is truly horrible is your stupidity and lack of care, Lil Schitty./.....Texas who just reopened a bunch of stuff has recorded its largest 2 day increase evah......And you ignore that to pursue your manic chase of rosy news like trump!!!!! 70k dead is a trivial problem to assholes like you and the goat fucking idiot and rat hole......Sad you hate humanity with such passion!!!!

anonymous said...

Funny Lil Schitty....it appears most americans prefer caution to opening the country....the new normal will be a far cry from the old in spite of you wishing like trump!!!!


By
Dan Balz and
Emily Guskin
May 5, 2020 at 6:30 a.m. EDT
Americans clearly oppose the reopening of restaurants, retail stores and other businesses, even as governors begin to lift restrictions that have kept the economy locked down in an effort to combat the coronavirus pandemic, according to a Washington Post-University of Maryland poll.
The opposition expressed by sizable majorities of Americans reflects other cautions and concerns revealed in the survey, including continuing fears among most people that they could become infected by the coronavirus, as well as a belief that the worst of the medical crisis is not yet over.
About half of states have eased restrictions on businesses, but Americans’ unease about patronizing them represents a major hurdle to restarting the economy. Many Americans have been making trips to grocery stores and 56 percent say they are comfortable doing so. But 67 percent say they would be uncomfortable shopping at a retail clothing store, and 78 percent would be uncomfortable eating at a sit-down restaurant. People in states with looser restrictions report similar levels of discomfort as those in states with stricter rules.

Americans continue to give President Trump negative marks for his response to the outbreak, while offering widely positive assessments of their state governors, a trend that has been consistent throughout the pandemic.
Trump’s ratings are 44 percent positive and 56 percent negative, in line with where he was two weeks ago and only slightly worse than a week ago. Governors earn positive marks from 75 percent of Americans, about the same as a week ago. Partisan differences remain sizable, with nearly 8 in 10 Republicans but just about 2 in 10 Democrats rating Trump positively. In contrast, governors earn big positive majorities across the parties.
Americans also overwhelmingly approve of the way federal public health scientists, including Anthony S. Fauci, have dealt with the challenges from the coronavirus. Fauci’s positive rating stands at 74 percent

Myballs said...

In 2018, judge Sullivan ordered the FBI to turn over all materials in their possession favorable to the defendant Flynn. They said they had. Clearly they lied to a federal court. Again.

They need to go to prison.

Myballs said...

Americans very much want to get back to work. The media doesnt want that though.

Myballs said...

With all this devastating news coming out about FBI criminality under Obama, where is Chris Wray? No one has seen now heard from him.

anonymous said...

They need to go to prison.

And serve in the cell next door to Flynn the lying asshole!!!!


Americans very much want to get back to work.


The poll I posted says otherwise you fucking moron!!!!!!

anonymous said...

The senate rejects bidens request to be transparent and release the Reade complaint!!!!! Now what assholes.....blame biden for hiding something when the senate is holding the cards?????/ You dumb fucks will bitch and moan and let trump get away with his BS pussy grabbing without a single hearing or sworn testimony!!!!!!!

Commonsense said...

And serve in the cell next door to Flynn the lying asshole!!!

Your hate is not facts,

In all likelihood his case will be dismissed with prejudice. He was a victim of such extreme abuse of police power I don't see how that will not be the case.

An abuse so egregious that the abusers themselves will be subject to prison.

Commonsense said...

The senate rejects bidens request to be transparent and release the Reade complaint!!!

Biden to release to the public the papers that are under his control.

Anonymous said...



Americans clearly oppose the reopening of restaurants, retail stores and other businesses...


and my suggestion to those "Americans" is simple -

stay the fuck home.

Anonymous said...



as usual, BWAA is too fucking stupid to grasp the facts -


But on Monday the secretary said the Senate legal counsel had reviewed relevant laws and, based on strict confidentiality requirements, advised that “the secretary has no discretion to disclose any such information as requested in Vice-President Biden’s letter of 1 May”.

The Biden campaign responded with three questions: can the Senate disclose whether the records exist; is there anyone to whom the records could be lawfully disclosed; and can the Senate release any procedures used by the office that would have overseen a sexual harassment complaint in the 1990s.

The decision left more questions than answers and was seized on by Republicans. Steve Guest, rapid response director for the Republican National Committee, wrote in an email: “Joe Biden’s attempt to offer faux transparency ground to a screeching halt this morning.”


https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/may/04/joe-biden-tara-reade-senate-records-reject-request

biden is a typical lazy fucking liberal. always begging everyone else to do their dirty work for them.

Myballs said...

So dopey chooses to cling to a WaPo poll instead of watching protests across the country by people wanting to return to work.

We don't call him dopey for nothing.

Anonymous said...

CDC and FEMA new "projections"
3,000 deaths a day for months.

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anonymous said...

The Protest where something James said would not happen.

Commonsense said...

At the worst of the pandemic in march the US never approached 3,000 deaths per day. So I don't really find the model particularly credible.

We'll see what happens in couple of weeks. The key statistic will be hospitalizations since they will lead deaths.

anonymous said...

Your hate is not facts,

And neither is your stupidity!!!!!!!!!!

Bet bidens papers come out before trumps tax returns you fucking asshole

anonymous said...

aid...
At the worst of the pandemic in march the US never approached 3,000 deaths per day.

Which in your fucked mind like trump is a win!!!!!!! Get back to me August 1 and lets see how the model you question did!!!! Amusing with your 8 grade education that you are now an expert in models!!!!!! BWAAAAAAAAAA!!!!!!!!

anonymous said...

nstead of watching protests across the country by people wanting to return to work.


And the fucking idiot ball less thinks a couple hundred people complaining is significant and polls are not!!!!!! BWAAAAAAAAAAA!!!!! God you are a stupid fucking asshole!!!!

Anonymous said...

China Created this Virus and unleashed it upon the world.

Anonymous said...

Markets just in
Stocks climb as US reopening gathers steam

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anonymous said...

August 1St, no need.
They started at 2.2 million Americans.

Wrong, but it scared the old Three Stooges.
In defense of lying Alky, he had no choice, he got locked down.

anonymous said...


August 1St, no need.
They started at 2.2 million Americans.

And you started with your head planted up trumps stupid old white ass!!!!! Why don't you go to topeka and mingle with a crowd of protesters to test how transmissible the virus is....!!!! You don't have any neighbors within miles.....why would you fucking worry??? You don't work and claim to be self sufficient......please enjoy your own form of lock down!!!!

anonymous said...

China Created this Virus and unleashed it upon the world.


And your parents created an idiot an america is still suffering !!!!!

Caliphate4vr said...

https://www.aier.org/article/elvis-was-king-ike-was-president-and-116000-americans-died-in-a-pandemic/

Elvis Was King, Ike Was President, and 116,000 Americans Died in a Pandemic

What’s remarkable when we look back at this year, nothing was shut down. Restaurants, schools, theaters, sporting events, travel – everything continued without interruption. Without a 24-hour news cycle with thousands of news agencies and a billion websites hungry for traffic, mostly people paid no attention other than to keep basic hygiene. It was covered in the press as a medical problem. The notion that there was a political solution never occurred to anyone.

Again, this was a very serious flu, and it persisted for 10 years until it mutated to become the Hong Kong flu of 1968.


The New York Times had some but not much coverage. On September 18, 1957, an editorial counseled: “Let us all keep a cool head about Asian influenza as the statistics on the spread and the virulence of the disease begin to accumulate. For one thing, let us be sure that the 1957 type of A influenza virus is innocuous, as early returns show, and that antibiotics can indeed control the complications that may develop.”

The mystery of why today vast numbers of governments around the world (but not all) have crushed economies, locked people under house arrest, wrecked business, spread despair, disregarded basic freedoms and rights will require years if not decades to sort out. Is it the news cycle that is creating mass hysteria? Political ambition and arrogance? A decline in philosophical regard for freedom as the best system for dealing with crises? Most likely, the ultimate answer will look roughly like what historians say about the Great War (WWI): it was a perfect storm that created a calamity that no one intended at the outset.

Anonymous said...

😀Fat Bottom Girl Denise😂

anonymous said...

Yep//////Open up everything!!!!! Seems very safe to me as thousands of new infections occur daily.....Please ignore NY's policy as bad as they were seem to be heading in the right direction as impatience takes over instead of caution!!!

inutes ago
18 minutes ago
Coronavirus Live Updates: Infection Rates Show the Threat Is Not Fading
Cases are growing by 2 to 4 percent daily, and more than 1,000 people have died each day for over a month. At least 15 children in New York were hospitalized with an illness scientists worry might be linked to Covid-19. Pfizer began human trials of a possible vaccine.

RIGHT NOWThe global death toll passed 250,000, and new estimates projected that daily deaths of Americans could soon reach 3,000.
Here’s what you need to know:

The reality of coronavirus in the U.S.: An unrelenting crush of cases and deaths.
An internal Trump administration report expects about 200,000 daily cases by June.
N.Y. doctors warn about a mysterious illness affecting children that might be tied to Covid-19.
California is to allow some stores to reopen and give counties more discretion in setting guidelines.
Senators are holding their first socially distanced hearing today.
Pfizer begins human trials for a potential vaccine.
Quarantine Diaries: Giving birth during the pandemic.

ImageA patient arriving at a hospital in Brooklyn on Monday.
A patient arriving at a hospital in Brooklyn on Monday.Credit...Dave Sanders for The New York Times
The reality of coronavirus in the U.S.: An unrelenting crush of cases and deaths.

While the worst-hit parts of the United States have seen new infections recede and hospitalizations drop after strict social-distancing measures were put in place, the country is still in the firm grip of a pandemic.
For every indication of improvement in controlling the virus, new outbreaks have emerged elsewhere, providing a steady, unrelenting march of deaths and infections.
As states continue to lift restrictions, impatient Americans are freely returning to shopping, lingering in restaurants and gathering in parks. New flare-ups and super-spreader events are expected to be close behind.
New Reported Cases by Day
As the New York metro area has seen a recent decline in new cases, the number of cases in the rest of the United States has steadily increased.

Source: New York Times database of reports from state and local health agencies and hospitals.·The New York City metropolitan area is defined by the U.S. Census Bureau and includes nearby cities and suburbs in Westchester, Long Island and northern New Jersey.
Julie Bosman, Mitch Smith and Amy Harmon report that any notion that the coronavirus threat is fading away appears to be magical thinking, at odds with what the latest numbers show.

anonymous said...

Dumb goat fucking moron again shits his brains......BWAAAAAAAAA!!!!!!

anonymous said...

Anonymous Caliphate4vr said...
https://www.aier.org/article/elvis-was-king-ike-was-president-and-116000-americans-died-in-a-pandemic/


An amazingly stupid opinion posted by an amazingly stupid Georgian!!!!!!!! BWAAAAAAPAAAAAA!!!!!

Anonymous said...

Fat bottom girl Denise.

ontinue Receiving more meals on wheels as you live in fear.

anonymous said...

And the goat fucking kansan takes another 4x4 to the head as his head killing one of 2 brain cells he had left...BTW....the other one is wounded!!!!! BWAAAAAAAAAA!!!!

Anonymous said...

"wise Latino" Sonia Maria Sotomayor
to old And stupid to use the technology to join in on digital arguements.

Anonymous said...

Fat bottom girl Denise, what nonsense.
Perfect troll .