In a major win for the Trump administration, the Supreme Court issued an order late Wednesday ending all injunctions that had blocked the White House's ban on asylum for anyone trying to enter the U.S. by traveling through a third country, such as Mexico, without seeking protection there.
The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals – long a liberal bastion that has been aggressively reshaped into a more moderate court by the Trump administration – handed the White House a partial victory in the case on Monday by ending the nationwide injunction against the asylum policy. However, the 9th Circuit kept the injunction alive within the territorial boundaries of the circuit, which encompasses California, Arizona, Alaska, Hawaii, Montana, Nevada, Idaho, Guam, Oregon and Washington.
Well there is actually more to this. From just two days ago:
U.S. District Judge Jon Tigar of the Northern District of California on Monday reinstated a national injunction blocking the Trump administration’s new asylum restrictions, after the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit initially limited the order to just the circuit’s geographic bounds.
Tigar wrote that while there may be circumstances in which a national injunction is inappropriate, the case before him—challenging a new rule that stops asylum seekers who pass through a third country before arriving at the U.S.’s southern border from being granted asylum—merits such an order.
So in essence, the District Judge ordered a national injunction. The 9th circuit court overruled it (sort of) by restricting the injunction to the 9th circuit boundaries. The District Judge then basically provided the 9th circuit appeals court a firm middle finger and reissued the same ruling again, basically overruling the superior court. It would seem, almost for spite.
Now that the USSC has stepped in, I would think whatever Tigar decides to do moving forward will not be followed by anyone. But I wouldn't put it past him to simply reissue his own ruling again (in spite of now being overruled by the circuit court of appeals and the USSC). He's an Obama judge. He might just be that arrogant.
This feels like an attempt to "delegitimize" the chain of judicial hierarchy. This is a system that relies on precedent and ruling authority. No district judge has the right to overrule the circuit court, and no circuit court has the right to overrule the USSC, and most certainly no district judges have any right to overrule the USSC.
12 comments:
Yuge Defeat for the 23 Dwarfs that love open borders.
"The consumer price index rose 0.1% last month, the government said Thirsday."
inflation is tame, the Three Socialist Stooges of CHT get another economic issue spectacularly wrong.
"U.S. unemployment benefits fell sharply to a nearly five-month low of 204,000"
I hope the Socialist Democrats keep praying for a recession .
As usual. The 9th circuit is the most overruled circuit.
Lots of judges there need to be replaced.
Technically they were overruling the district judge before the 9th had a chance to rule. But they also effectively overruled the previous 9th ruling that allowed this to remain in place.
The problem here is that these judges (Sotomayor and Ginsburg) need to understand that sometimes there is more at stake than just the politics of the case.
This should have been 100% about whether a district judge can order a national injunction, especially after being overruled previously by a circuit appeals court. But the two liberals made it about the merits of the case (which was not at issue yet)... which is just an invitation for lower court judges to ignore the precedents and order of the courts in favor of simply finding an excuse to rule on the politics.
Moody analytics wrote that the trump trade wars have cost 300 k jobs!!!! And our lil scotty worries of a back bencher running for POTUS....May he can bottom the goat fuckers new gun to make him feel like a hot shit Wonder how many new polls have trump under 40%?????
.May he can bottom the goat fuckers new gun to make him feel like a hot shit
Jeeez what the fuck???
Off the rails again.
Moody analytics wrote that the trump trade wars have cost 300 k jobs!
We are at 3.8% unemployment rate. Literally the lowest it has been in over 19 years. You expect me to believe that our current economic policies are "costing jobs"!
Funny stuff. You got a whole routine, Denny... or just this one joke?
exactly wtf....
"May he can bottom the goat fuckers new gun to make him feel like a hot shit "
7.2 million jobs are currently available in the USA that are unfilled.
Job Openings and Labor Turnover Summary - Bureau of Labor Statistics
PressOffice@bls.gov JOB OPENINGS AND LABOR TURNOVER – JULY 2019 The number of job openings was little changed at 7.2 million on the last business day of July, the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reported .
The Three Socialist Stooges of CHT are Economic and Financial retards.
Post a Comment